With the story about Stephen Hawking the other day claiming that Pope John Paul II said "“It’s OK to study the universe and where it began. But we should not inquire into the beginning itself because that was the moment of creation and the work of God.” in a conference on cosmology I figured it would not be long till we had the actual quote from the Pope and that it would be quite different than what was represented.
‘Every scientific hypothesis about the origin of the world, such as the one that says that there is a basic atom from which the whole of the physical universe is derived, leaves unanswered the problem concerning the beginning of the universe. By itself science cannot resolve such a question….’ The pope then quoted Pope Pius XII as saying, ‘We would wait in vain for an answer from the natural sciences which declare, on the contrary, that they honestly find themselves faced with an insoluble enigma.’
[Via the Catholic League]
So I guess since the real quote is not represented by what the esteemed Stephen Hawking said I guess we could just say it had been swallowed by a black hole in his memory or that it had been gravitationally distorted by brain cells being to close to someone thinking deeply about event horizons.
5 comments
It was a conference on cosmology, not cosmetology, right? There’s only so many things that Hawking can makeup (pun intended). π
Did he blush for hawking his erroneous lip shtick? Or did he use a cover-up for that? It’s amazing what some people mascara-ade as the truth.
Ever since reading “A Brief History of Time”, I have realised that Hawking is viciously opposed to any traditional belief. He is a prime example of what Lewis referred to as the religion of scientism.
Makes you wonder how intelligent he really is if he can’t even pull out an accurate meaning from a quotation. Even my sister in grade 10 could get it right.
Sounds like pseudo-science agendas are creeping in… Forget cosmology more like astrology.
Allan, that was my first thought. He may be a brilliant astro-physicist, but he seems to have a hard time extrapolating plain English.