Being an armchair pundit you get to see in general how the media covers a story. Even when they print the same article as other outlets they often also put their own headline to it. Today in a story on the canonization of Gianna Beretta Molla the headline read “Pope Canonizes Anti-Abortion Activist.”
I wouldn’t exactly categorize St. Gianna Beretta Molla as an Anti-Abortion Activist. She died in 1962 well before the passage of abortion laws in Italy in 1978. She was a doctor and specialized in pediatrics and gave special attention to mothers, babies, the elderly and the poor.
In September of 1961, at the age of 39, Blessed Gianna was pregnant with her fourth child when physicians diagnosed a large ovarian cyst which required surgery. The surgeon suggested that Gianna undergo an abortion in order to save her own life. Gianna’s decision was prompt and decisive: “I shall accept whatever they will do to me provided they save the child.” She underwent the surgery but her fate was sealed. The following year, on Good Friday, Gianna was admitted to Monza Maternity Hospital. Her daughter, Gianna Emanuela, was born the next day but Blessed Gianna expired seven days later, on April 28, 1962.
When a parent returns into a burning building to rescue a child and they die in the act, are they branded as a child activist? If a parent jumps into the water to rescue their drowning child and they die saving the child, are they branded as a child activist? No instead we see these stories in the light of a parents love. Parents in these situation did not chose directly to die, but instead were working towards saving their child’s life. When these stories appear in papers they don’t have the negatively charged headlines that Mollas’ case has gotten. Some pro-abortion groups have complained about her canonization because they say it means that the child’s life is worth more than the mothers. Of course these same groups preach that the child’s life should never inconvenience the mother. They in fact are the ones that hold one life as more important than another. This of course is not what the Church teaches.
“Every human being, even the infant in the mother’s womb, has the right to life immediately from God, not from the parent or any human society or authority. Therefore there is no man, no human authority, no science, no medical, eugenic , social, economic or moral “indication” that can show or give valid juridical title for direct deliberate disposition concerning an innocent human life – which is to say, a disposition that aims at its destruction either as an end in itself or as the means of attaining another end that is perhaps in no way illicit in itself. Thus, for example, to save the life of the mother is a most noble end, but the direct killing of the child as a means to this end is not licit…” (Pope Pius XII, Allocution to Italian Midwives, 10/29/51)
Again it is not an either/or situation but a both/and. Fr. Mateo had this to say on the subject.
Pope Pius XI, in his encyclical on Christian Marriage (December 31, 1930): “What could ever be a sufficient reason for excusing in any way the direct murder of the innocent? This is precisely what we are dealing with here. Whether inflicted upon the mother or upon the child, it is against the precept of God and the law of nature: ‘Thou shalt not kill.'”
The words “upon the mother or upon the child” should be carefully noted. It is a calumny to say that the Church always prefers the life of the infant to that of the mother. Catholic teaching has always been that each life is inviolable and neither may be directly killed to save the other.
The principle that the life of both mother and child is sacred and inviolable is a life-saving principle. In the long run it saves many lives that might have been lost. Doctors who know they have no right to sacrifice either life are much more likely to find means of preserving both lives than are doctors who readily employ direct therapeutic abortion.
I find this to be most true that a doctor who fights for both lives will more likely save both. Here is a recent story that emphasizes the opposite of this point.
BILOXI, May 12, 2004, (LifeSiteNews.com) – Jacobina Surian Adams, 82, has died; she is survived by her daughters, 11 grandchildren and three great-grandchildren. One of those daughters would not be alive today if it had not been for her mother’s faith and courage.
In 1962, while two-months pregnant with her daughter Laverne, Jacobina was diagnosed with breast cancer and the doctors recommended an abortion. Jacobina refused and went on to give birth and defeat breast cancer. The Adams’ are devout Catholics and they credit their mother with instilling her faith in them. “As we were growing up, we never went into the car without saying the rosary,” said Laverne Burdine, the youngest daughter. “We never missed church.” (source)
Abortion activists who are always screaming about choice will at the same time decry the choice of now St. Gianna Beretta Molla.
9 comments
They scream for choice so long as they agree with the choice made. St. Gianna, pray for us all.
Women who jump into burning buildings to save their child aren’t made into saints. This is all about making an anti-abortion point, nothing more.
Bet you’re all disappointed the baby she died for was a girl. What a waste, eh?
Kate,
What an extremely ignorant and stupid statement.
If a person lived a life of holiness and then died saving their child in a building; they might be declared a saint. St. Gianna lived that life of heroic holiness. People are not declared a saint for one event.
And your statement about “what a waste” is just to ignorant to answer intelligibly.
You might try learning what the Catholic Church believes about the sanctity of life before making such dumb statements. But since you probably think that murdering a child in the womb is okay, your statements are no surprise.
It’s most likely this headline resulted from a careless reading of the first paragraph of the story by a copy editor, and someone who became an icon of anti-abortion activism (true) becomes such an activist herself. Just sloppy headline writing. Don’t read so much into it.
Just because somebody IS out to get you doesn’t mean you can’t also be paranoid, to twist Woody Allen’s famous bon mot.
I am a medical doctor,and St.Gianna is one of my patron saints.An unselfish love for others,fear of God,and submission to the will God are her characteristics that we should emulate.We are all pilgrims in this world,and we should be preparing for our own destination while we are still here on earth.Animals act through their instincts,while we as humans,created by God in his own image and likeness,must also be Christ-like.This is what distinguishes us from other creatures. All in this world is fleeting-beauty,material wealth,fame,we will leave these when we die.What is important is the destination of our soul.
I am a medical doctor,and St.Gianna is one of my patron saints.An unselfish love for others,fear of God,and submission to the will God are her characteristics that we should emulate.We are all pilgrims in this world,and we should be preparing for our own destination while we are still here on earth.Animals act through their instincts,while we as humans,created by God in his own image and likeness,must also be Christ-like.This is what distinguishes us from other creatures. All in this world is fleeting-beauty,material wealth,fame,we will leave these when we die.What is important is the destination of our soul.
Well, this Gianna is an example of motherhood! What a woman! We need more like this in our church. Too bad about the pro-abortionists. She lay down her life for her child. I note that there has already been a miracle attributed to her. Now, here’s one to pray to! May God keep her daughter! A good example of Catholic.
Well, what a woman! A good example of Catholic.A good example of motherhood. She lay down her life for her child. Now, here’s one to pray to, especially if mothers have problems with childbirth. There has already been one miracle attributed to her. Gianna would now be one of my favourite saints.
I am trying to get holy cards or some info on St Gianna so I can tell people more about her. No one at daily mass has heard of her.
mary