Theodore R. Connors, whose daughter was a seventh-grader at West Middle School this spring, said an English class assignment requiring pupils to write a suicide note was highly inappropriate.
“It’s a very dark, dark assignment,” he said.
Connors, who recently ran unsuccessfully for the Auburn school board, wants the assignment dropped next year and said the school district should advise parents of pupils who completed the assignment to talk with the children about suicide.
Auburn School Superintendent John Plume said Wednesday he didn’t think the assignment, as described by the school’s principal, was inappropriate.
Plume said he’s talked to the principal three times about the issue since it first came to light and that Connors has reached a conclusion that “is not based on fact.”
“I’m not a teacher, but I know that’s not an appropriate assignment,” Connors said late last week. “So how is it a teacher would not think that that’s not an appropriate assignment?”
[Full Story]
I think I would go farther then calling this “highly inappropriate”, this is just plain wrong and evil. Requiring seventh graders to think up reasons why they should kill themselves and to put this to paper is total lunacy. What I can’t believe is that they need to stop it from happening next year also. I wonder what they do for a science project – build a Kevorkian death chamber?
And while we are on topic of “Pubwick Educkatshun” here is another story:
NEW ORLEANS (AP) – Apparently the truths in the Declaration of Independence aren’t so self-evident. When Rep. Roger Wicker asked high school seniors in his Mississippi district to name some unalienable rights, he got silence. So the Republican congressman gave the advanced-placement history students some help.
“Among these are life,” Wicker said, “and….”
“Death?” one student said. So much for liberty and the pursuit of happiness.
“It’s not so much that they don’t know the rote phrases and facts,” said Wicker, the sponsor of a House bill to improve civics instruction. “It just demonstrates a real gap in the education of young Americans.”
[Full Story]
This was bad enough, but an “advanced-placement history” class, the cream of the crop of students studying history.
8 comments
I read your blog nearly every day, and have admired you for stating the truth eloquently. I realize that this is from the article you sited, but the word is “inalienable”, not “unalienable”, just like John Adams'(Harvard) and Thomas Jefferson’s (William and Mary) conversation in the movie 1776. So maybe the students were just taken aback (ha, ha).
Another argument for homeschooling….
They should give the teacher and administrators an assignment: why I got a lobotomy.
I just read a copy of the Declaration posted at Josh Claybourn’s site. If he has copied it accurately, the word is “unalienable.”
Either (inalienable or unalienable) is a correct spelling, but “unalienable” is the one used in the Declaration.
What Kind of Homework
Writing a suicide note doesn’t make for good composition.
It was a very very cruel and rude and stupid and scary assignment!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Does anyone know anything about the movie “1776” we are doing an assignment called “Hollywood vs. History” and I can’t find anything about this thing. Please help!!
Comments are closed.